Beyond Yes and No: Using Tarot to Navigate Hard Decisions

Suzanne Butler
2 days ago
6 min read

There’s a particular kind of discomfort that comes from standing at a crossroads and realising that none of the options feel clean.

You’re not deciding between yes or no. You’re deciding between versions of yourself. Between timing and readiness. Between what feels true now and what might feel safer later.

This is often the moment people turn to tarot hoping for clarity — a single card, a definitive answer, a cosmic thumbs-up or down. And sometimes tarot obliges. But more often, especially with hard decisions, it doesn’t. Instead, it complicates things. It asks questions back. It refuses to reduce a living, breathing situation into something binary.

And honestly? That refusal is a feature, not a flaw.

Hard decisions usually aren’t hard because we lack information. They’re hard because more than one truth is present at the same time. We want relief and growth. Safety and expansion. Rest and movement. A yes/no framework can feel tempting here, but it can also quietly bypass the real work — which is learning how to sit with complexity without rushing ourselves into certainty.

This is where tarot stops being an answer machine and starts becoming something much more useful: a way of listening.

Not listening for what to do, exactly — but for what’s being stirred, resisted, avoided, or quietly longed for beneath the question. The cards don’t always tell us which path to take. Sometimes they illuminate why the decision feels heavy in the first place.

And that, gently but firmly, changes how we move forward.

Why Yes/No Questions Collapse Living Decisions

Yes/no questions promise relief.

They offer the fantasy of clean edges: Do this or don’t. Stay or go. Now or never. When we’re overwhelmed or tired of circling the same thoughts, that kind of simplicity can feel like oxygen.

But most meaningful decisions aren’t static problems — they’re living processes. They unfold over time. They respond to our nervous systems, our histories, our hopes, and our capacity in any given moment. Trying to flatten that into a yes or a no can feel a bit like asking a tide to choose a direction and stick with it.

This is where tarot often starts to feel “unclear,” when really it’s just being honest.

A yes/no spread might technically answer the question — but it often sidesteps the more important ones:

What am I actually afraid will happen if I choose this?
What part of me wants this, and what part is resisting it?
What am I not ready to let go of yet?
What would support look like if I moved in this direction slowly?

When we ask tarot to decide for us, we can miss the invitation to understand ourselves. And for hard decisions, that understanding is usually what makes the difference — not the decision itself, but how we arrive at it.

A softer approach isn’t about avoiding commitment or staying stuck in indecision forever. It’s about recognising that clarity often comes sideways. Through insight. Through reflection. Through naming what’s already true but not yet fully conscious.

Tarot, at its best, doesn’t close doors with a firm yes or no. It opens rooms. It lets us walk around inside the question, notice what catches our breath, what tightens our chest, what brings a surprising sense of calm. From there, decisions stop feeling like verdicts and start feeling like conversations — ongoing, responsive, and deeply human.

Asking Questions That Can Hold the Whole Truth

When the question changes, the experience changes too.

One of the most supportive things you can do when you’re facing a hard decision is to loosen your grip on the answer and become more curious about the landscape. Instead of asking tarot — or yourself — to deliver a final verdict, you can ask questions that make room for nuance, timing, and care.

This isn’t about avoiding responsibility. It’s about recognising that some decisions need to be met in stages.

Questions like:

What is this situation asking me to learn right now?
What am I trying to protect myself from?
What would moving forward gently look like?
What needs more attention before I decide anything?

These kinds of questions don’t demand immediacy. They allow the truth to emerge in layers. And often, they reveal that the decision itself isn’t the problem — it’s the pressure we’re putting on ourselves to be certain before we’re ready.

Tarot responds differently to these questions. The cards tend to feel more spacious, more reflective. They show patterns instead of outcomes. Dynamics instead of destinations. And while that can initially feel frustrating, it’s often far more supportive in the long run.

Because clarity doesn’t always arrive as a lightning bolt. Sometimes it arrives as a quiet knowing that builds over time. A subtle shift in how you talk about the situation. A softening around one option. A growing discomfort around another. Tarot can help track these movements — not to rush them, but to notice them.

And perhaps most importantly, this approach gently returns authority to where it belongs: with you.

The cards aren’t here to overrule your intuition or override your lived experience. They’re here to help you listen more closely — especially when the path forward isn’t obvious yet.

Letting Decisions Ripen Instead of Forcing Them

There’s a quiet kind of courage in admitting, I don’t know yet.

Not as a resignation, but as an act of self-trust.

We’re often taught that uncertainty is a problem to solve as quickly as possible. That if we just think harder, pull another card, ask one more opinion, clarity will finally click into place. But some decisions don’t respond well to pressure. They need time. Space. A little warmth. Much like fruit on a branch, they ripen in their own rhythm.

Tarot can be especially helpful here — not by speeding things up, but by slowing us down enough to notice what’s already shifting.

You might pull the same themes repeatedly. The same card, the same emotional response, the same internal resistance. Rather than seeing this as “being stuck,” it can be useful to ask: What is still forming? What hasn’t been integrated yet? What would be lost if I rushed this?

Sometimes the most supportive choice isn’t to decide — it’s to tend. To care for the parts of you that are anxious for resolution. To acknowledge the grief embedded in choosing one path over another. To allow your nervous system to feel safe enough to imagine change.

This doesn’t mean waiting forever or avoiding responsibility. It means recognising that readiness is real. And when it arrives, decisions often feel quieter than we expect — less dramatic, more settled. Less like a leap, more like a step that makes sense in your body.

Tarot, in this space, becomes less about prediction and more about companionship. A way of checking in as things evolve. A mirror that reflects back where you are now, not where you think you should be.

And sometimes, gently, that’s enough to let the next step reveal itself.

Choosing Without Forcing: A Softer Way Forward

Hard decisions rarely ask us to be braver, smarter, or more certain.

More often, they ask us to be kinder with ourselves in the not-knowing.

When we step away from yes/no frameworks, something subtle but important shifts. Decisions stop feeling like tests we might fail and start feeling like relationships we’re in — with our values, our limits, our desires, and our capacity in this season of life. Tarot, used this way, doesn’t demand answers. It supports awareness. It helps us notice where we’re already moving, even when we haven’t named it as a choice yet.

If you’re standing in uncertainty right now, it doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong. It may simply mean you’re listening closely. You’re allowing the decision to take the shape it needs, rather than forcing it into one that feels prematurely final.

You might gently ask yourself:

What feels most true today — not forever, just today?
Where am I craving certainty, and what’s underneath that need?
What would it look like to choose the next small, supportive step instead of the whole path?

These aren’t questions that demand immediate resolution. They’re questions that create steadiness. And from steadiness, clarity tends to emerge on its own time.

If this way of working with uncertainty resonates — if you’re drawn to decision-making as a process of healing, self-trust, and deep listening — you may find support in The Healing Journey. It’s an invitation to explore your inner landscape gently, without pressure to be fixed or figured out, and without reducing your lived experience to simple answers.

Sometimes the most meaningful choices aren’t about deciding once and for all. They’re about learning how to stay present with yourself as the path unfolds.

And that, in itself, is a powerful kind of knowing.

Ready to go deeper into healing and intentional growth through tarot? Explore The Healing Journey, our step-by-step guided experience for transformation.

Liked this piece? Follow me for more soulful tarot reflections, healing frameworks, and tools for intuitive growth. Or visit www.the-healing-tarot.com to explore our courses and offerings.

#tarot #decisions #spiritualgrowth #tarotcommunity #loveandlight #healingtarot #wayforward